General remarks
Interesting alternative to my proposal. I would say: nice try but I am finding a lot of shortcomings, especially in regards of skewed focus and lack of inclusivity.
This proposal is also a bit less sophisticated with the allocations. It leaves a lot open, probably intentionally - but it leaves the reader with some questions still.
Elements 1, 2 and 5 (DCA, Limit and Staking) can easily be gamed with multiple wallets doing small volumes due to the very high 100 JUP base allocation you envision for each categorie. There is no minimum requirement which is tricky.
The DCA and Limit orders are too nice specific to receive an equal allocation of 140M JUP relative to Swap volume which most people use. Only 1.3% of users is using the DCA or Limit order function, leaving out 98.7% of Jupiter users.
On Solana when people want to buy or sell a memecoin, they’ll just swap SOL for that coin or the coin back to SOL. DCA and Limit is a niche trading functions. There’s no specific reason to push or promote it that much. Most people don’t use it.
Putting so much focus on DCA and Limit puts too much JUP in the hands of a 189,249 - 211,049 traders, while greatly disadvantaging regular swap users.
These ~ 200,000 traders only represent 1.3% or 1 / 77th of all 15.5 Million users. The other 98.7% of users is neglected in the proposal.
Even when only considering the 3,885,443 with $100+ volume users of Jupiter, you’re still leaving out nearly 95% (~ 200,000 vs 3,885,443).
The proposal furthermore neglects and excludes some very important user tiers.
This is leaving out 5.2 Million mostly legitimate users, who are the average memecoin traders on Solana / Jupiter. The $1,000 - $10,000 tier of 1,419,121 users is strongly neglected, as well as the $100+ general tier of 3,885,443 users.
- $10M+ tier¹: 40M JUP / 4,422 users = 9,045 JUP per user
- $1M - $10M tier: 70M JUP / 31,920 users = 2,193 JUP per user
- $100K - $1M tier: 100M JUP / 182,332 users = 548 JUP per user
- $10K - $100K tier: 100M JUP / 664,448 users = 150 JUP per user
- $1K - $10K tier: 100M JUP / 1,419,121 users = 70 JUP per user
- All $100+ users²: 40M JUP / 3,885,443 users = 10 JUP per user
- $0 - $100 wallets²: No Allocation / 11,361,557 users = 0 JUP per wallet
Data remarks
About the Limit Order dashboard, the data isn’t correct. The data input stops somewhere around June where volume drops 95% - 99%.
I also found the DCA link (not yet included in your post sources). The DCA dashboard seems to have correct volume data https://dune.com/ilemi/jupiter-dca